Showing posts with label fate. Show all posts
Showing posts with label fate. Show all posts

Monday, January 03, 2011

Twists of Fate 4

In Twists of Fate 3, I mentioned some cases where it seems natural to personalize fate, and attribute him with a cruel sense of humour.

We might also attribute the following example to a personalized fate with a perverse sense of humour.
NYC jumper saved by trash uncollected since storm
26-year-old leaped from ninth floor apartment and landed on pile of refuse. His aunt told the New York Post it was lucky the city had the snow and hadn't cleared the garbage.
MSNBC 3 January 2011 via @milouness

Lucky but undignified.

Monday, July 19, 2010

Twists of Fate 3

Journalists sometimes use the phrase "cruel twist of fate" when a person or family suffers more than one occurrence of the same loss or injury. Charmaine Kennedy whose boyfriend and ex-husband are both shot by gunman Derrick Bird. Frances Culling, who has watched her husband and four children die of the same genetic disorder, and now fears losing her remaining daughter and grandchildren. These people are unlucky, but there is no twist involved - unless you count the irony of Mrs Culling's surname.

I think the phrase properly applies to those cases where it seems natural to personalize fate, and attribute him with a cruel sense of humour. Two of the following examples have a good-news-bad-news structure, the third follows the frying-pan-into-fire pattern, and the fourth is an example of being "hoist" (blown up) by one's own "petard" (bomb). There may be other patterns.


A miner who lived through the worst pit disaster in a county because of a twist of fate died in a similar accident nearly 30 years later on the other side of the world.

Northern Echo 13 February 2009


A woman who survived a ferocious "death roll" crocodile attack in the wild has been killed after being bitten by a snake in her garden.

Daily Mail 4 March 2008

A schoolboy was killed when he walked on to a busy motorway after arguing with his father at a wedding.

Crawley News 18 July 2010, Daily Mail 18 July 2010


Jimi Heselden, the British philanthropist and owner of Segway Inc., tragically passed away on Sunday after an accident involving an off-road model of his own company's famous two-wheeled vehicle.

AOL News, 27 September 2010

Thursday, July 15, 2010

Twists of Fate 2

"A mother drowned in a freak car crash as she drove home to tell her husband she had beaten breast cancer. Jean Allen, 66, had been forced to take a detour after arsonists set fire to a church and caused massive traffic disruption." [Cambs Times 15 July 2010, Daily Mail 15 July 2010]

The tabloid newspapers make far too much use of the word "tragedy", but maybe this is one of those examples where the cruel humour of fate does justify the word.

The bereaved husband is calling for the arsonists to be tried for manslaughter. “I don’t want vengeance, I just want justice." But this seems an odd idea of justice: I think the arsonists (if caught) should be tried for arson; and I doubt that threatening them with a more serious offence is helpful in getting someone to turn them in.

The arsonists may have been partially responsible for her driving along that particular stretch of road at that particular time, but in that case the oncologists are also partially responsible. Meanwhile, the local authority failed to drain the ditch in which she drowned.
 
Surely the point about twists of fate is that they are beyond human agency? We can imagine some cruel purpose behind any series of events, especially when we are able to construct some kind of meaningful narrative, but that doesn't mean that such a purpose really exists.

Saturday, September 06, 2008

Twists of Fate

September 6th. John McCain's appointment of Sarah Palin is a brilliant gamble, and may yet win him the White House. Whether the world wants a brilliant gambler in the White House is another matter, but I don't get the impression that many Americans are asking themselves that question. The focus is not on whether the decision is risky but on whether the decision is right or wrong.

Update: But see Joseph Lelyveld, "John & Sarah in St. Paul", New York Review Volume 55, Number 15 · October 9, 2008

Meanwhile, the spectacle of Democrats gossipping and speculating about Palin's disabled son and unmarried daughter is not only shameful but possibly also counter-productive. Attack her political record and opinions, for God's sake, not her family.

One of the things I do find interesting about her family is their unusual names. Her daughter is called Bristol, a city historically associated with the tobacco industry. And her son is called Trig Paxon Van Palin, which makes him sound like a rock star.

Paxon? I turn to the internet, where I find an old car company and a Marxist called Homer Paxon. And (now this looks as if it might be more relevant) a right-wing Republican called Bill Paxon, whose wife Susan Molinari was once talked of as a potential rival to Hillary Clinton.

Paxon's Wikipedia entry has two mysterious footnotes [1] [2] referring to the suicide in 1998 of a young journalist called Sandy Hume, together with rumours that he had been having a homosexual relationship with a Republican politician. Paxon quit politics three days after the suicide to spend more time with his family. Nearly thirty years previously, Sandy Hume's father had been responsible for a press story exposing an alleged homosexual relationship involving Spiro Agnew's son. Twists of fate indeed.

But why is Sarah Palin's son named after Paxon? Think about it. If you want to distract people from your extreme opinions and bloodthirsty hobbies, why not spread a few false clues that lead scandal-seekers astray?