Showing posts with label police. Show all posts
Showing posts with label police. Show all posts

Sunday, October 31, 2021

Contagion

The mathematician and broadcaster Hannah Fry did some post-doctoral research modelling social disturbance and crime in terms of contagion. In 2014, she gave a presentation at a conference in Berlin about her work with the police attempting to model the patterns of the 2011 London riots. As she said later, it didn't occur to her that a Berlin audience might have a different perspective on police power than a British audience would, and she got (in her words) absolutely torn apart. 2018 video 11:20

Several members of the audience expressed concerns about handing over too much control to the police, not only in giving them the power to suppress different forms of disturbance, but also in biasing the data on which the mathematical models were based. One person asked whether the data could really represent who the rioters were, referring to sociological research showing that police arrests are anything but neutral ... underprivileged groups of society tend to be arrested more. 2014 video 55:40

Another person noted how the riots depended not only on the behaviour of the rioters and the police, but also on the behaviour of the bystanders, which varied in different parts of London. If the Turkish community on London dealt robustly with the situation without relying on the police, this might be linked to the relationship between police and public in Turkey. In her response, Fry also noted the influence of the British media on the behaviour of bystanders in such situations.

While noting concerns about privacy, and agreeing that handing over too much control to technology is a really scary thing, Fry attempted to balance this against the claim that there is something positive to be gained by looking at the macro level behaviour of people in the way that we can design our society. 2014 video 52:50

In her more recent talks, Professor Fry has been more careful to put mathematical modelling into an ethical frame, as well as encouraging people to question the authority of the algorithm.

When it comes to algorithms, you can't just build them, put them on a shelf, and decide whether they're good or bad in isolation. You have to think about how they are actually going to be used by people. 2018 video 11:40

Once you dress something up as an algorithm or as a bit of artificial intelligence it can take on this air of authority that makes it really hard to argue with. 2018 video 26:10

Peter Polack provides a more fundamental challenge to the something positive claim. He traces the genealogy of this idea from August Comte's social physics to latter-day neorationalism, referencing Michel Foucault's notion of biopower and biopolitics.

Meanwhile, if social disorder appears to follow the same mathematical patterns as contagious disease, and the police are being invited to treat crime as a disease, perhaps it is not surprising when disease (or even the possibility of being infectious) starts to be treated as a crime.

The protective measures during the COVID pandemic include lock-down and self-isolation. So-called social distancing really means physical distancing, with as much social interaction as your technology (from phones to Internet) can provide. This is a lot easier for people with reasonably large houses, good internet connections, and devices for each member of the family, as well as the kinds of jobs that are relatively easy to do from home. For people in cramped housing, and for people who actually need to turn up at work if they want to get paid, self-isolation is a luxury they may not be able to afford. Therefore being tested for COVID may also be a luxury they can't afford.

Hannah Fry's mathematical model of the London riots identified that many of those arrested were from disadvantaged areas, although as we've seen this finding can be interpreted in more than one way. A model of disease might also show increased infection in disadvantaged areas. Maps of disadvantage and disease show strong persistence over time, as I discuss in my post on Location, Location, Location, quoting a study by Dr Douglas Noble and his colleagues.

But the COVID testing data are not going to show this pattern if people from disadvantaged areas are reluctant to come forward for testing. So much for biopower then.



Hannah Fry, I predict a riot (re:publica 2014, May 2014) recording via YouTube

Hannah Fry, Contagion: The BBC Four Pandemic (BBC March 2018) recording not currently available

Hannah Fry, Should Computers Run the World (Royal Institution, November 2018) recording via YouTube

Douglas Noble et al, Feasibility study of geospatial mapping of chronic disease risk to inform public health commissioning. BMJ Open 2012;2:e000711 doi:10.1136/bmjopen-2011-000711

Peter Polack, False Positivism (Real Life Mag, 18 October 2021) HT @jjn1

Stanford Encyclopedia of Philosophy: August Comte, Michel Foucault

Related posts: Location, Location, Location (February 2012), Algorithms and Governmentality (July 2019), Algorithmic Bias (March 2021)

Thursday, January 21, 2016

Spelling Crimez

According to news reports, a ten-year-old child recently got a visit from the police after writing that he lived in a 'terrorist' house. 

Given that the family was Muslim, the Internet jumps to the conclusion that there was some racial stereotyping going on here. A day or so earlier, the Prime Minister had announced a fund (or at least partially reversed previous cuts to such funding) to teach Muslim women to speak English (which would presumably include learning the correct spelling of such words as 'terraced').

If the police were serious about gathering intelligence about potential extremists in the community, and if they believed that this was a genuine lead to an extremist family, you'd have thought they would want to treat the boy as a valuable source of information, rather than immediately alerting the family that they were under suspicion. What purpose does a home visit achieve, apart from shock and awe.

The authorities have responded to the news reports, claiming that the home visit was not prompted solely by a single misspelling, there were a number of issues arising from the child's schoolwork, and that it had not been regarded as a terror incident. The home visit had been done by a social worker, accompanied by a PC.

According to the boy's cousin, the boy is now scared of writing, or using his imagination. Arguably that's not a good use of police time, when a bit of well-timed sarcasm by a schoolteacher can achieve that outcome much more efficiently.


Update. Apparently what the boy actually wrote was this.
"I hate it when my uncle beats me. I live in a terrorist house with my uncle."
So what happened within the family after the social worker (accompanied by the PC) leaves? And what happened within the community when the media sensationalized the story? Can anyone use some imagination?



Rahila Bano, Muslim boy, 10, probed for 'terrorist house' spelling error (BBC News 20 January 2016)

Mario Cacciottolo, How much of a problem is speaking English for some Muslim women? (BBC News 18 January 2016)

Aisha Gani, Lancashire police criticise BBC over 'terrorist house' story (BBC News, 21 January 2016)

Lancashire 'terrorist house' row 'not a spelling mistake' (BBC News 20 January 2016)

Bill Jacobs, 'We've done nothing wrong' - Teachers and police respond to 'terrorist house' 'overreaction' (Lancashire Telegraph, 21 January 2016)


Updated 21 January 2016

Friday, February 29, 2008

DNA and Crime 2

In a police state, anything that makes the police more effective is a Good Thing.

We are being bombarded with various measures (actual and proposed) that apparently make the police more effective. Longer detention-without-trial for terrorist suspects. CCTV evidence. And a national DNA database.

Proponents of these measures never fail to slip positive messages into the news media.

On the one hand, here's a terrible crime that was fortuitously solved many years later, *thanks to* the brilliant intervention of DNA scientists. On the other hand, here are some terrible crimes that may never be cleared up, *because* the relevant DNA wasn't recorded.

On the one hand, here is a wicked terrorist whom we were forced to release after a mere 28 days, although we *knew* he was plotting something terrible. On the other hand, here is another wicked terrorist, whom we were able to prosecute *because* the evidence just happened to emerge after a mere 45 days of investigation.

Opponents of these measures sometimes argue that they are ineffective or inaccurate. It is implausible to believe that evidence will suddenly appear after 28 days that was not available before. They say they will only agree to this measure if it can be shown that it sometimes works.

Other opponents argue that they are disproportionate. They do not deny that they may possibly work in a few cases, but claim that the benefits are grossly outweighed by the illiberal side-effects.

The problem with both of these lines of argument is that they are vulnerable to constructed refutation. Detection can be attributed to DNA for crimes that might possibly have been solved by other means. Suspected terrorists can be detained for the maximum permitted period, not just because the investigators are under less pressure to find evidence more quickly, but also because the investigators need to demonstrate that the currently permitted maximum is barely enough. Under certain conditions, the statistics could start to look very favourable, enough to overcome the "disproportionate" argument.

And the supporters of these measures have a further argument up their sleeve - the hypothetical deterrent effect. Imagine how many more crimes might have been perpetrated: would-be criminals who saw the cameras, or remembered the DNA held hostage in the police database, and decided to stay home and watch Big Brother instead. Imagine how many more people might have attempted to smuggle dangerous chemicals or stiletto heels onto aeroplanes, if it had not been for the constant vigilance of dedicated security screeners.

My point is this. Opponents of some specific measure may declare that the measure is unacceptable or counter-productive in a civilized society, may declare that the measure could only be accepted if such-and-such facts could be produced. And they may believe that this opposition is fairly solid, because these facts are extremely unlikely.

But what if the advocates of these measures are able to influence the facts? ...

Of course, I am not saying we are in a police state today. I am not even saying that specific measures would turn our country into a police state. All I am saying is that it is possible to see how repeated application of certain lines of argument could result in a police state.

Update


Here's some evidence to support my conjecture: